50 Gallon Water Heater Installation and Repair in Schererville, IN

Reichelt Plumbing installs, repairs, and replaces 50 gallon water heaters for homes in Schererville, IN and the surrounding Northwest Indiana communities. Fully licensed, bonded, and insured, our team is BBB A+ rated, has served Northwest Indiana since 1986, and is reviewed on Google Reviews and HomeAdvisor. A 50 gallon tank does not deliver the same amount of hot water in every home: a standard gas model and a standard electric model of that size have very different first hour ratings, so we size by household demand and fuel type, not tank volume alone. We install Bradford White, AO Smith, and State tank water heaters, confirm a flat-rate price before work begins, and back qualifying installation and repair work with an 18-month guarantee. Call (219) 322-4906 to schedule 50 gallon water heater service in Schererville.

Water heater leaking or running short? Call Reichelt Plumbing at (219) 322-4906 for 50 gallon water heater installation and repair in Schererville.

Is a 50 Gallon Water Heater the Right Size for Your Home?

Tank volume does not tell you how much hot water a household will get. The U.S. Department of Energy defines the first hour rating as the number of gallons of hot water a heater can supply per hour, and says it depends on the tank capacity, the source of heat, and the size of the burner or element. The EnergyGuide label lists it in the top left corner as capacity (first hour rating). To size a heater, the Department advises totaling the hot water your household uses in its busiest hour and choosing a model whose first hour rating is at least equal to that total.

He was professional, explained everything very well and did an awesome job.

“I needed the sewer rodded in my front yard because it was backed up. Within an hour, Sam showed up. He was professional, explained everything very well and did an awesome job. We've had this problem in the past and Sam was basically cleaning up what they left behind (A huge ball of roots). This was the first time we weren't left with an uneasy feeling about whether the job was really done right or not. We will definitely be using them for future plumbing services.”

- Rocio C.

Read More Reviews Request Service

AO Smith’s builder’s guide gives a quick reference by household size. This table sets that chart beside the first hour ratings the same guide lists for standard 50 gallon gas and electric models.

The guide lists more than two full baths among the signs of a high-demand household and advises those households to consider moving up to the next first hour rating level. Ratings also vary by design: the same guide lists 50 gallon direct vent, power vent, smart electric, and heat pump models with first hour ratings from 65 to 119. Treat the table as a starting point and let real habits decide the rest, such as back-to-back showers, a soaking tub, or laundry run during the morning rush.

If the table shows that a smaller tank would do, our 40 gallon water heater covers that size. For help weighing the options, our guide to choosing the right water heater walks through the decision.

Gas or Electric: Why Two 50 Gallon Tanks Can Perform Differently

Fuel type changes what a 50 gallon tank can do. Gas burners recover faster than standard electric elements, so a gas tank can supply a larger household than an electric tank of the same capacity. This table uses AO Smith’s published specifications for its standard atmospheric vent gas and standard electric 50 gallon models. Other brands and models list different figures, so we check the specification sheet for the exact unit before we recommend it.

Electric units need no flue, which can simplify installation where venting is difficult. Gas units need a correctly sized gas supply and a vent that carries exhaust out of the home, so the installation details matter more.

For homes served by NIPSCO, its gas line responsibilities states that the customer owns the gas lines from the meter to the gas appliances, and it advises finding a qualified professional to maintain gas appliances rather than doing the work yourself. Our natural gas water heater covers gas installations, and our tank water heater covers conventional tank units in general.

Hard Water, Lake Michigan Supply, and Your 50 Gallon Tank

The Town of Schererville’s 2025 water quality report states that the Water Department purchases pretreated water from Indiana-American Water, which relies on surface water from Lake Michigan. Indiana American Water’s 2024 report for its Northwest Indiana system lists hardness of 134 to 150 ppm, described as naturally occurring, and names Schererville, Crown Point, Merrillville, Hobart, Portage, Valparaiso, and Chesterton among the communities it serves.

The USGS classifies water at 121 to 180 mg/L as calcium carbonate as hard, and explains that when hard water is heated in a home water heater, solid deposits of calcium carbonate can form. That scale can reduce the life of equipment and lower the efficiency of electric water heaters. In a tank, the minerals settle on the bottom as sediment, which is why flushing the tank and checking the anode rod matter in this area. Neighboring towns can draw from other water systems, so hardness can differ, and your utility can confirm yours.

Sediment often announces itself as popping or rumbling during a heating cycle. Our post on how sediment buildup creates strange water heater noises explains the pattern, and our explainer on hard water versus soft water covers the water itself.

Will a 50 Gallon Tank Fit? Space, Height, and Venting

A replacement tank is not always the same size as the one it replaces. Ahead of the 2015 federal standards, ACEEE noted that the height and/or diameter of some conventional products would increase 1 to 2 inches due to added insulation. AO Smith’s guide lists its standard atmospheric vent 50 gallon gas models at 22 inches in diameter and 57-1/4 inches to the top of the tank, and its standard electric models at 20-1/2 inches in diameter and 60-1/2 inches to the top of the tank. Some power vent, direct vent, and power direct vent models are taller overall, with listed heights of 66-3/4 to 74 inches, while the guide’s short and lowboy models have tank heights of 34 to 49-3/4 inches and diameters of 23 to 26-1/2 inches.

Closets, basement corners, and garage alcoves can be tight when a larger tank replaces a smaller one. We measure the space, the clearances, the vent path, and the drain location before we order a unit. Our posts on water heater placement and performance, undersized venting problems, and the 2015 water heater standards explain what to check.

50 Gallon Water Heater Services in Schererville

We handle the full life of a 50 gallon tank, from sizing and installation to repair, maintenance, and replacement.

Installation and Replacement

A complete installation covers removing the old unit, setting and leveling the new tank, connecting the water supply, and making the gas or electrical connection. We install the temperature and pressure relief valve with proper discharge piping, set up the vent on gas units, and add a drain pan where the location calls for one. We also check whether the plumbing needs a thermal expansion tank, confirm the permit requirements, and test the unit before we leave. Our post on common water heater installation mistakes lists what to look for in any installation.

Water Heater Repair

Many problems are repairable when the tank is still sound: a failed thermostat or heating element on an electric unit, a thermocouple, pilot assembly, or gas valve on a gas unit, a worn relief valve or drain valve, or a depleted anode rod. Our guide to troubleshooting a water heater thermostat explains common thermostat problems. A leak from the tank itself usually means replacement, and our post on what to do when a water heater leaks covers the first steps.

Maintenance

Regular maintenance keeps a 50 gallon tank performing as it should: flushing out sediment, inspecting the anode rod, testing the relief valve, and checking the burner or elements. On hard water, these checks matter more. Our water heater maintenance tips list what to do between visits, and our post on finding the pressure relief valve shows where it is and why it matters.

Upgrades and Type Changes

Some households outgrow a 50 gallon tank, and others would rather stop storing hot water at all. We can move up or down in capacity, change fuel type when the home allows it, or switch to a tankless water heater. Our guide to tank versus tankless water heaters compares the two.

Emergency Water Heater Leaks

A tank that is leaking needs prompt attention. Shut off the cold-water supply to the heater and turn off its power or gas, then call. Our 24/7 emergency plumbing team responds day and night.

Brands We Install

We install Bradford White, AO Smith, and State tank water heaters, and we match the model to the home’s fuel type, venting, space, and peak hot water use. See all of our water heater services.

Signs Your 50 Gallon Water Heater Needs Attention

• Water pooling at the base of the tank or around the fittings
• Rust-colored or discolored hot water
• Popping or rumbling sounds during heating
• Hot water running out sooner than it used to
• A relief valve that drips or discharges
• A pilot light that will not stay lit on a gas unit
• A unit approaching 10 to 15 years old, the typical lifespan for a storage water heater according to the Department of Energy

Not every symptom means the same thing. This table shows what each one often points to and which direction the fix usually takes.

Our post on water heater repair versus replacement explains how we weigh the two.

Temperature, Safety, and Efficiency

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission urges users to lower their water heaters to 120 degrees Fahrenheit. We set the temperature at installation and show you how to adjust it. Our posts on the ideal water heater temperature and keeping the setting right to prevent burns explain the trade-offs.

Permits, Gas Safety, and Licensing in Schererville

The Town of Schererville’s building permit requirements list water heaters among the plumbing fixtures on the permit application, include underground, rough, and final plumbing inspections, and state that no work is to be started without a permit displayed at the job site. The packet does not address water heater replacements separately, so we confirm what a job requires with the Town and handle the paperwork. Gas appliance work belongs with a qualified professional, as NIPSCO advises, and you can verify any plumber’s state license with the Indiana Professional Licensing Agency.

Our 50 Gallon Water Heater Process in Schererville

1. Call (219) 322-4906 or send a service request and tell us the household size, the current water heater, and the problem.
2. A licensed technician inspects the existing unit, the fuel supply, the vent, the water connections, and the space.
3. We review your peak hot water use and recommend a size, fuel type, and model based on the first-hour rating.
4. You receive a written flat-rate price before work begins.
5. We handle the permit and any inspection the job requires.
6. We remove the old unit and install the new tank with the relief valve, discharge piping, vent or electrical connection, and drain pan where needed.
7. We test the unit, check for leaks and proper venting, set the temperature, and show you the shutoff valves and controls.
8. We review maintenance with you, and qualifying work is covered by our 18-month guarantee.

Why Schererville Homeowners Choose Reichelt Plumbing for Water Heaters

50 Gallon Water Heater Facts Worth Knowing

• Sizing: AO Smith’s chart calls for a first hour rating of 45 to 55 gallons for 2 people, 65 to 75 for 4 people, and 85 to 100 for 6 people.
• Ratings: AO Smith’s standard 50 gallon gas models list a first hour rating of 84, and its standard 50 gallon electric models list 62.
• Dimensions: AO Smith’s standard gas models measure 22 inches across and 57-1/4 inches to the top of the tank, and its standard electric models measure 20-1/2 inches across and 60-1/2 inches to the top of the tank.
• Water: Schererville buys pretreated Lake Michigan water from Indiana-American Water, whose 2024 report lists hardness of 134 to 150 ppm.
• Lifespan: the Department of Energy says storage water heaters typically last about 10 to 15 years.
• Temperature: the Consumer Product Safety Commission urges users to lower water heaters to 120 degrees Fahrenheit.
• Gas: NIPSCO states that the customer owns the gas lines from the meter to the appliances.
• Permits: the Town of Schererville’s permit application lists water heaters among the plumbing fixtures it counts.

Frequently Asked Questions: 50 Gallon Water Heaters in Schererville, IN

What is a 50 gallon water heater, and which households is it sized for?

A 50 gallon water heater is a storage tank that holds 50 gallons of heated water. How many people it serves depends on the fuel type, because gas burners recover faster than standard electric elements. On AO Smith’s household chart, a standard 50 gallon gas model, rated at 84 gallons in the first hour, covers households of up to five people, and a standard 50 gallon electric model, rated at 62, covers households of up to three.

What is a first hour rating, and why does it matter more than tank size?

The U.S. Department of Energy defines the first hour rating as the number of gallons of hot water a heater can supply per hour, and says it depends on the tank capacity, the source of heat, and the size of the burner or element. Two 50 gallon tanks can have very different ratings. The rating appears on the EnergyGuide label, and the Department advises choosing a model whose rating is at least equal to your household’s busiest hour of hot water use.

Is a 50 gallon water heater enough for a family of four?

It depends on the fuel type. AO Smith’s chart calls for a first hour rating of 65 to 75 gallons for four people. A standard 50 gallon gas model is rated at 84, which exceeds that range, while a standard 50 gallon electric model is rated at 62, which falls below it. The guide lists a 50 gallon smart electric model at 74 and a 50 gallon heat pump model at 66, so some electric designs fall within that range. The guide lists more than two full baths as a sign of high demand and advises such households to consider moving up to the next first hour rating level.

What size water heater do I need for a three-bedroom house?

Bedrooms are only a rough guide, because hot water use follows the number of people and their habits. AO Smith’s chart is built on household size: three people need a first hour rating of 55 to 65 gallons, and five people need 75 to 85. A three-bedroom home with a larger household or more than two full baths may need a higher rating than the bedroom count suggests, so we size from your busiest hour of use at the visit.

Should I choose a 40 gallon or a 50 gallon water heater?

Compare first hour ratings, not tank size alone. In AO Smith’s guide, the standard gas models are rated 80 at 40 gallons and 84 at 50 gallons, while the standard electric models are rated 53 at 40 gallons and 62 at 50 gallons, so the move from 40 to 50 gallons adds the most hot water on electric units. A 40 gallon unit can serve a smaller household with staggered use, and a 50 gallon unit suits larger households, back-to-back showers, and homes with more than two full baths. The larger tank is also wider, at 22 versus 20 inches across for the standard gas models and 20-1/2 versus 18 inches for the standard electric models, so we check that it fits the space.

What is the difference between a gas and an electric 50 gallon water heater?

In AO Smith’s guide, a standard gas model lists a first hour rating of 84 and a recovery rate of 42 to 43 gallons per hour, while a standard electric model lists 62 and 21 gallons per hour. Gas units need a vent and a gas supply. Electric units need an electrical supply but no flue. We check the home’s existing fuel and venting before recommending a type.

How big is a 50 gallon water heater, and will it fit my space?

AO Smith lists its standard atmospheric vent 50 gallon gas models at 22 inches in diameter and 57-1/4 inches to the top of the tank, and its standard electric models at 20-1/2 inches in diameter and 60-1/2 inches to the top of the tank. Some power vent and direct vent models are taller, with listed heights of 66-3/4 to 74 inches, and the guide also lists short and lowboy models for tight spaces. ACEEE noted that the 2015 standards would add 1 to 2 inches to the height or diameter of some products, so a replacement can be larger than the unit it replaces. We measure the space, clearances, and vent path before we order. Our post on water heater placement and access explains why access matters.

How long does a 50 gallon water heater last?

The U.S. Department of Energy says storage water heaters typically last about 10 to 15 years. Warranty terms vary by model, and AO Smith’s guide lists limited tank warranties of 6, 8, and 10 years across its lines. Hard water, sediment, and maintenance habits all influence where a particular unit lands in that range.

Where does Schererville’s water come from, and how hard is it?

The Town of Schererville’s 2025 water quality report says the Water Department purchases pretreated water from Indiana-American Water, which relies on surface water from Lake Michigan. Indiana American Water’s 2024 report for its Northwest Indiana system lists hardness of 134 to 150 ppm, described as naturally occurring. The USGS classifies water at 121 to 180 mg/L as calcium carbonate as hard. Neighboring towns may use other water systems, so hardness can differ.

How does hard water affect a 50 gallon water heater?

The USGS explains that when hard water is heated in a home water heater, solid deposits of calcium carbonate can form, and that this scale can reduce the life of equipment and lower the efficiency of electric water heaters. In a tank, the minerals settle as sediment on the bottom, which can cause popping or rumbling. Regular flushing and anode rod checks address the buildup.

Should a 50 gallon tank be flushed, and how often?

Yes. A flush removes sediment before it builds into a layer that affects heating and adds stress to the tank. We recommend flushing at least once a year, and the water in this area is a good reason not to skip it. Our guide to improving your water heater’s efficiency lists annual flushing among its five steps.

What does the anode rod do?

The anode rod is a sacrificial metal rod inside the tank that corrodes in place of the steel tank walls. Once it is substantially depleted, the tank itself can begin to corrode. AO Smith’s guide notes that some of its models use a stainless steel core to extend the life of the anode rod and that some notify the user when the anode is consumed. We inspect the rod during maintenance and replace it when needed.

What temperature should I set a 50 gallon water heater to?

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission urges all users to lower their water heaters to 120 degrees Fahrenheit. We set the temperature at installation and show you how to adjust it.

What is a T&P relief valve, and what if it drips?

The temperature and pressure relief valve opens to release water if the temperature or pressure in the tank rises too high. A valve that drips or discharges should be evaluated, since it can point to excess pressure or temperature or to a worn valve.

Why does my water heater make popping or rumbling noises?

The sounds usually come from sediment on the bottom of the tank. Water trapped beneath the mineral layer heats and escapes as steam bubbles, which creates the popping. A flush often reduces the noise, while heavy buildup in an older tank may point toward replacement.

Why is my hot water rusty or discolored?

Rust-colored hot water, when the cold water runs clear, often points to corrosion inside the tank, commonly after the anode rod has been depleted. A flush can clear loose sediment, but persistent discoloration usually means the tank is corroding. Our post on what to do about rusty-looking water explains how to tell where the rust comes from.

Why is my water heater leaking?

Leaks come from a loose or corroded fitting, a worn drain valve, a relief valve that is discharging, or the tank itself. Fittings and valves can often be repaired, while a leak from the tank body means the tank has failed. Shut off the cold-water supply to the heater and turn off its power or gas, then call.

Can a 50 gallon water heater be repaired, or does it need replacement?

Many problems are repairable when the tank is sound, including thermostats, heating elements, thermocouples, gas valves, relief valves, and anode rods. A leaking tank, persistent rust, or a unit near the end of its typical 10 to 15 year lifespan usually points toward replacement. We evaluate the failure and the age of the unit before recommending either.

Why does my 50 gallon water heater run out of hot water?

Common causes are a unit too small for current demand, sediment that reduces heating performance, a failed heating element or thermostat on an electric model, or a burner or gas valve problem on a gas model. Changes in the household, such as more people or a new soaking tub, also matter. Your busiest hour of use, set beside the unit’s first hour rating, shows whether size is the cause.

Why will the pilot light on my gas water heater not stay lit?

A pilot that keeps going out often points to a worn thermocouple, a dirty pilot assembly, a gas valve problem, or a draft issue at the vent. The label on the heater gives the manufacturer’s lighting instructions. If the pilot goes out repeatedly, call a professional to diagnose it, because NIPSCO advises finding a qualified professional for gas appliance work.

Do I need a permit for a water heater in Schererville?

The Town of Schererville’s building permit packet lists water heaters among the plumbing fixtures counted on the permit application and states that no work is to be started without a permit displayed at the job site. It does not address replacements separately, so we confirm what a particular job requires with the Town and handle the paperwork and inspections.

Who is responsible for the gas line to my water heater?

If NIPSCO is your gas utility, it states that it owns and regularly inspects the gas lines up to and including the gas meter, and that the customer owns the lines from the meter to the gas appliances. NIPSCO advises against doing the work yourself and recommends a qualified professional for gas appliances. If you smell gas, go outside and call 911 first.

Which brands of 50 gallon water heaters do you install?

We install Bradford White, AO Smith, and State tank water heaters. We match the model to your fuel type, venting, space, and peak hot water use, and we check the exact unit’s specification sheet for its first hour rating and dimensions before we order.

What is the difference between atmospheric vent, power vent, and direct vent gas water heaters?

An atmospheric vent unit relies on a flue and natural draft to carry exhaust out. A power vent unit uses a blower to push exhaust through a vent pipe, which allows horizontal runs to an exterior wall. A direct vent unit draws combustion air from outside through a sealed system. AO Smith’s guide lists first hour ratings for its 50 gallon gas models from 71 to 119 depending on the design and model, with its standard atmospheric vent models at 84. The right choice depends on the home’s venting path and hot water demand.

Should I consider a tankless water heater instead of a 50 gallon tank?

A tankless unit heats water on demand and removes the storage tank, which suits households that want to save space or that run short with a tank. It needs adequate gas supply capacity and sometimes venting or electrical changes. A 50 gallon tank is the simpler swap when the existing connections already fit. Our posts on gas supply planning for tankless heaters and why many homes are not built for tankless units explain what to check.

How do I find out how old my water heater is?

The serial number on the rating plate usually encodes the manufacture date, and the format differs by brand. Our guide shows how to tell the age of your water heater. The age, compared with the Department of Energy’s typical 10 to 15 year lifespan, helps decide between repair and replacement.

What does a 50 gallon water heater installation involve?

We inspect the existing unit and its connections, confirm the size and fuel type, and handle the permit. We then remove the old unit, set the new tank, connect the water supply and the gas or electrical supply, install the relief valve and discharge piping, set up the vent on gas units, and test the unit for leaks and proper operation. The timeline depends on whether it is a like-for-like swap or involves changes to fuel, venting, or location, and we explain the plan at the visit.

Which areas near Schererville do you serve for water heater installation?

We install and repair water heaters in Schererville, Dyer, St. John, Munster, Highland, Griffith, Crown Point, Merrillville, Hobart, Cedar Lake, Lowell, Valparaiso, Portage, Chesterton, and Hammond, along with the rest of Northwest Indiana and South Cook County, Illinois.

How is 50 gallon water heater installation priced?

We quote a flat-rate price based on the unit, the installation, and any required changes to venting, fuel, or location, and we confirm it in writing before work begins. Current offers on qualifying service are listed on our plumbing coupons page.

How do I schedule 50 gallon water heater installation or repair in Schererville?

Call Reichelt Plumbing at (219) 322-4906 or send an online service request. Water heater leaks are answered 24/7, and qualifying installation and repair work carries an 18-month guarantee.

BBB A+ Rating | Google Reviews | HomeAdvisor | Facebook Reviews